Writer’s Prompt: The Devil’s Advocate: A Noir Tale of Ethics and Evidence

Spread the love

He held the evidence that could end a monster, but it would mean killing his career. In the shadows of the law, there is no such thing as a clean win.

Writer’s Prompt

The neon sign outside Josh’s office hummed with a low-frequency dread, flickering “JUSTICE” in a rhythmic, dying gasp. Inside, the air smelled of stale coffee and the kind of secrets that rot from the inside out.

Josh stared at the manila folder on his desk. It wasn’t just paper; it was a tombstone. Inside were the photos—the real ones—showing his client, Miller, standing over the girl with a look of bored indifference. The police had missed them. The DA was flailing. And Josh, the “principled” defense attorney, was the only soul on earth holding the noose.

Miller was a predator who viewed the world as a buffet of victims. If Josh followed the code—the sacred, dusty ethics of the bar—he’d bury this evidence, win the case on a technicality, and watch Miller walk out into the rain to find his next target.

His thumb hovered over the “Send” button on an anonymous email addressed to the Lead Prosecutor. One click, and he’d be a traitor to his profession. One click, and he’d be a hero to the ghost of a girl who never got to grow up.

The ethics board would call it professional suicide. Josh just called it a Sunday night. He looked at the bottle of rye in his drawer, then back at the “Send” icon. The hum of the neon sign grew louder, mocking him.

The choice wasn’t about the law anymore. It was about whether he wanted to wake up tomorrow and be able to look at his own reflection without wanting to break the glass.

How would you finish this story?


Discover more from Optimistic Beacon

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Optimistic Beacon

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Verified by MonsterInsights